I really really really love these product so so much!!! Absolutely amazing! Obsessed!

Great Great Great Great Great I love it Great Great Great Great Great I love it Great Great Great Great Great I love it

Great product. No smudge and easy to use

It's really as the product says, it's very simple to use. I usually never use eye pencils because I don't draw on my eyes but whenever I want to switch up I can use this product because It's very simple to use. Recommend it

I have oily eye lids and also get teary during allergy season and this eye liner does not budge through all of those seasons. I like all of their brown tone and once you draw it in, it stays put all day until you take it off. It's the best!

I love this mascara. Not make my eyes look like pandas even I have oily eyelids. But little bit pandas when I draw inner eyelids. Easy to drawing with skinny eyeliner.

I really like how lasting it was during the day. It smudged very little, however I do wish the product had a little more product . Overall, it was great .

really good product. when i use it, it make my face feel so comfortable.

Favorite eyeliner. Doesn’t smear when dried but blends very easily when first applied!

I really really really love these product so so much!!! Absolutely amazing! Obsessed!

my go to eye liner! very fixable/erasable, the dark brown is the best one, also very smooth application!

my go to eye liner! very fixable/erasable, the dark brown is the best one, also very smooth application!

my go to eye liner! very fixable/erasable, the dark brown is the best one, also very smooth application!

I love CLIO products and have been using their pen eyeliner for years. i wanted a pencil to have in case the pens started to dry out or if i run out. I used this pencil on my upper lash line. It is not quite that smooth so it drags a bit when you apply it. By the end of the night I looked like a panda. It definitely smudges. I’ll keep trying this but I can’t give it a five rating right now.

I am very satisfied as it does not smudge under my eyes.

This eyeliner really stays in place. Doesn’t budge even after rubbing my eyes many times throughout the day.

It's easy to draw and the color is really suitable

Great eyeliner to make a sharp wings.

I like it it’s not bad I recommend

smudges on the outer and inner corners of eyes. does not stay on long

So easy to use for beginners. I use dark brown shadow to lined my wing on top with this and it stays all day

I have oily eye lids and also get teary during allergy season and this eye liner does not budge through all of those seasons. I like all of their brown tone and once you draw it in, it stays put all day until you take it off. It's the best!

So simple eyeliner I love that it has a little glitter on it

Gives a natural finish. It's good

This stays on all day even on my oily eyelids. Forever will repurchase

I think I found my favorite eyeliner

Good product good product good product good product

Nice eyeliner, smooth applicator, natural look for your eye

Very long lasting and doesn’t smudge easily

provide deep hydration to skin without leaving any sticky feeling