For an oil cleanser, it does it's job, but I have a few issues with it. I don't think I like oil cleansers as much as balms because I feel like there's so much wasted product left on hands. In addition, this pump spurts the product out very quickly and very far. I don't like it's herbal scent, it's a little off-putting. But it does it's job and I am being super nitpicky!