I can't live without double cleansing. It's the only way to remove everything from my sunscreen, to the BB cream to dirt and oil. I have always used Banila and i love it. I haven't seen any difference in the pink or the green or the yellow so far. They all remove all traces of make-up right away. I noticed that this very gently removes waterproof eye make-up too, so you don't need to rub. However, if you use the Japanese Hero mascara, you might need additional eye makeup removers. I would recommend this product !!