top 3 favorite mascara! was looking for a tubing mascara and found this, did not disappoint! formula is a little wet but does not weigh down curled lashes. easy to remove with warm water because tubing mascara. i wear contact lenses and it did not irritate my eyes. sometimes will have little fallout flakes by the end of the day but i don’t mind because i kinda expect from tubing mascara. lashes don’t stay curled for 5+ hour wear