If you want to try a velvet lip tint I definitely recommend this because of the pricing and quality! I have fallen in love with Peripera lip tints lately! They are so affordable and cute! The shade I got was a bit too bright red for me. I got shade #002 celeb deep rose. The picture makes it look really rosey but when you try it its pretty red looking. I used this specific lip tint for my graduation makeup and it did smudge on my mask. :/ But the pigment was definitely still on my lips. Tbh I been reaching for the peripera ink drop tint a lot more. Why? Because it doesn't smudge and feels great on my lips! Definitely try it even if you prefer matte lip tints like me!