I have not tried the banilla zero clean, so I can't make any comparisons. But out of all the oil/solid cleansers or makeup removers, this has been my favorite. It completely removes my makeup, and it doesn't leave a weird residue on my skin after I've rinsed it off with water or foam cleanser.

This is such an awesome cleansing balm. It really does a good job in removing makeup and leaves my skin very soft. Will re-purchase again and again!

This has got to be my favorite cleansing balm! It gets all the gunk off my face before I use my cleanser.

This is the first time i tried this item. i does remove makeup and it doesn't dry my skin

Works just like the banila co one and i prefer this lid over the banila co one

One of my favorite cleansing balm,

It has worked wonders. Removes makeup easily and you just have to use a little amount. Perfect as first cleanser. Nothing but good things about this product.

It's a good oil cleanser, it leaves the sking super clean and bright.

My second purchase. I llloooovee this oil cleanser. Melts away my makeup easily.

This takes it all off and keeps my skin soft. It lasts a long time and removes makeup so well.

Literally on my 5th one. It's perfect for sensitive skin.

This is my go-to. I used up at least 5 tubs of this already. Doesn't leave greasy film, smells great.

Removes even waterproof mascara! It can leave your vision a little blurry if it gets in your eyes but it goes away after a couple of minutes.

Love this cleansing balm & love that they revamped it to hold the spoon/scooper.

Love the new revamped packaging for a slot to put the spoon. Love this sherbet cleansing balm. 

It's the first and only ‘first cleanser’ I've ever used, but why looking for something better when you already found the perfect product? Melts away the makeup as a dream, especially mascara which was always a nightmare to remove. Way better than Banila Co.

My fave cleansing balm of all time! I use it to remove sunscreen and occasionally makeup! No clogging, no leftover greasy residue, and no tightness when I wash it all off! No regrets!

Works effectively and does not burn my eyes. So good.

melts smoothly and helps me take of my makeup easily

This is the one good cleansing balm. I can see now why a lot of people are using it especially YouTubers. It really gets all the make up off which is what I love most about it, but, then again that is the purpose of it. I have used different cleansing balm’s before, but this one in particular is one of my top favorites because it is just so good. I especially love how it is solid, but once you touch it, it melts. It also makes me look like I am melting when I am removing my make up with it LoL! Yeah, so if you were looking for a really really good cleansing balm, I recommend this Heimish cleansing balm to everybody out there! Oh! And one more thing I also love the little spatula that it comes with, it is so cute.

I used to use Banila Co cleansing balm, it always leaves oily cast that feel not thoroughly cleansed. But after using Hemish, this one is perfect for me. My skin feels very clean, and soft, not drying... after removing all my makeup. It smells quite strange, not perfumy so I think that's why it is very gentle, not eye irritating. Highly recommend!!!!!

Just finished my second tub, love it

Better than the Banila Co cleansing balm in my opinion, as it can be washed off easily with water but is still strong enough that it removes all makeup, even waterproof mascara! The packaging is well designed as well.

this is a great balm to remove makeup!

Have always been to my go to make up remover

I use this when I am wearing make up and then I follow it up with a foaming face cleanser. It's great and I got it for a great price. Very happy.

This is my numer one make up remover! Love this Product ❤️❤️❤️

I LOVE THIS NEW PACKAGING. it makes everything so clean, keeps the applicator separate from the product

it takes alll make up off, even most stubborn waterproof mascara, very gentle, nice scent to it too, been using it ever since it came out loveee

I’ve tried this. I’ve tried Banila Co. And I loved this more. It feels like it’s healing my skin and not just cleansing it.