I've used over 7 containers of the Round Lab Cica Pine toner pads. I absolutely love them but felt wasteful with the packaging, cotton pads, and excessive plastic despite Terracycling the empties. I've been hoping that round lab would offer the toner in a bottle so that I could minimize my eco footprint and was ecstatic when I saw this. However, there's something different about this toner that I didn't absolutely love like I did with the toner pads. I emptied this but won't be repurchasing.