Good

Good mascara, although not very special. It gives some volume and length to my lashes but it's comparable to a lot of other mascaras. I haven't noticed it smudge yet, although a good solution for any mascara to stop smudging is to lightly powder it after application.

 

not bad
it last the whole day, however it clumps when you put it on your lashes so i have to re brush it with a clean brush

Tubing mascara

This is a tubing mascara and I love it. It works best in thin coats. I plan to repurchase. 

It's ok.

This mascara is ok.  Not too bad.  Doesn't clump or smudge.