Liquid Liner
This unfortunately didn't work for me. I tried. I put setting spray...but it dried, then flaked off every time.

Best lipliner I have used ever
Waterproof and sweat proof than any other eyeliner

My line
Really Good and love it

Good eyeliner
I using it everyday after got it. Early to apply and not smudge for whole day.

Good
Easy to apply and not smudge for whole day. Love it