My fav
I’ve been using it for years, quality is good and does the job

It’s okay
I can get sharp lines, but it kind of run dries if you take too long to draw your eyeliner, maybe after 2 minutes. I was able to draw fake bottom lashes, picture below!

Nice brush, but not so nice ink
I wanted to like this product because I wanted to get a good, brown eyeliner with brush tip, The brush is really good, but the product isn't. don't know what's the issue, but it isn't pigmented enough, I guess, because it misses some spots and no matter how many times I go back to color in, it still looks tacky. It's really durable, though, smudgeproof and waterproof, I could only take it off with the cleansing oil.

Bushra
I loved it, but its color tends to be black

Great liner
This is my daily liner, I go between both colors. The brown is a great brown, doesn't come across as dark orange like a lot of them. It stays in place all day for me and doesn't flake. My last black I just opened was actually dried out but I'm hopeful that it was just a one-off flaw.