Pretty but doesn't last
not very opaque, comes off super easy, but points for easy application

My fav
I’ve been using it for years, quality is good and does the job

It’s okay
I can get sharp lines, but it kind of run dries if you take too long to draw your eyeliner, maybe after 2 minutes. I was able to draw fake bottom lashes, picture below!

Nice brush, but not so nice ink
I wanted to like this product because I wanted to get a good, brown eyeliner with brush tip, The brush is really good, but the product isn't. don't know what's the issue, but it isn't pigmented enough, I guess, because it misses some spots and no matter how many times I go back to color in, it still looks tacky. It's really durable, though, smudgeproof and waterproof, I could only take it off with the cleansing oil.

Bushra
I loved it, but its color tends to be black